Have you ever made an ice cream cake? I made one for the first time this week.
When I was asked if I was available to make a birthday cake I said, “Sure. I’d love too!” When asked if I did ice cream cakes, I had a bit of a RUT-ROH moment. (Sorry, I’m a bit of a Scooby- Do fan) I didn’t want to disappoint or pass up an opportunity to try something new; I took the order.
Then came the question, ” Do you think you could make a little boat to put on top?” Again I said, ” Sure, I can do that.” Shortly after I got this picture.
There was a brief moment of panic, but I was going to make this happen. I knew she wasn’t expecting an exact replica of the boat.
Turns out this is one of the easiest cakes I have ever made. Not to mention I think it turned out pretty cute.
This cake was made using pound cake and Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia Ice Cream. Any cake and ice cream combination can be used
To make an ice cream cake you will need:
- 2 round 9 inch cakes using your favorite recipe
- 2 pints of your favorite ice cream, softened
- 1 large tub of Cool Whip, thawed
Step 1: Bake your cakes. Once cakes have cooled wrap in plastic wrap and freeze for an hour
Step 2: Line your cake pan with plastic wrap. Spread the softened ice cream evenly in the pan. Place in freezer an hour.
Step 3: Remove the cake and ice cream layers from the freezer. Stack layers on a cake board or plate. The bottom layer should be cake.
Step 4: Apply a thin layer of Cool Whip to cover the top and sides of the cake. Place in freezer for an hour.
Step 5: Remove cake from freezer and cover with a final, thicker layer of Cool Whip. Decorate cake how ever you wish. Make sure to work fast, to avoid melting ice cream. ( I took too long trying to get my Cool Whip perfectly, perfect and the ice cream started melting. Emergency repairs were necessary. WHOOPS)
Step 6: Freeze for several hours; over night is best.
Take cake out of freezer 10-15 minutes before serving. Cut cake with a knife that has been run under warm water.
Each week you can find me linking to these fun parties.













Awesome cake! I haven’t tried to decorate an ice cream cake before – what pressure to have to work so quickly! My cakes do go back in the fridge every second I’m not working on them tho. Very pretty!
WOW! I think the boat is perfect! And the waves!….amazing! Cake sounds awesome too….sure would love that cherry ice cream.
What a beautiful and super unique cake!!
Amazing job
I’m so tickled you shared this at Weekend Potluck. Great cake!
Wow! That’s amazing! Love the cake too.
Thanks Dorthy! I really enjoyed making this cake