Cherry Garcia Ice Cream Cake

Have you ever made an ice cream cake? I made one for the first time this week.

When I was asked if I was available to make a birthday cake I said, “Sure. I’d love too!” When asked if I did ice cream cakes, I had a bit of a RUT-ROH moment. (Sorry, I’m a bit of a Scooby- Do fan)  I didn’t want to disappoint or pass up an opportunity to try something new; I took the order.

Then came the question, ” Do you think you could make a little boat to put on top?” Again I said, ” Sure, I can do that.” Shortly after I got this picture.

There was a brief moment of panic, but I was going to make this happen. I knew she wasn’t expecting an exact replica of the boat.

Turns out this is one of the easiest cakes I have ever made. Not to mention I think it turned out pretty cute.

  This cake was made using pound cake and Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia Ice Cream. Any cake and ice cream combination can be used

To make an ice cream cake you will need:

  • 2 round 9 inch cakes using your favorite recipe
  • 2 pints of your favorite ice cream, softened
  • 1 large tub of Cool Whip, thawed

Step 1: Bake your cakes. Once cakes have cooled wrap in plastic wrap and freeze for an hour

Step 2: Line your cake pan with plastic wrap. Spread the softened ice cream evenly in the pan.  Place in freezer an hour.

Step 3: Remove the cake and ice cream layers from the freezer. Stack layers on a cake board or plate. The bottom layer should be cake. Step 4: Apply a thin layer of Cool Whip to cover the top and sides of the cake. Place in freezer for an hour.

Step 5: Remove cake from freezer and cover with a final, thicker layer of Cool Whip. Decorate cake how ever you wish. Make sure to work fast, to avoid melting ice cream. ( I took too long trying to get my Cool Whip perfectly, perfect and the ice cream started melting. Emergency repairs were necessary. WHOOPS)

Step 6: Freeze for several hours; over night is best.

Take cake out of freezer 10-15 minutes before serving. Cut cake with a knife that has been run under warm water.

If you would like to keep updated on all the happenings at DJ’s Sugar Shack please be sure to “like” me on Facebook!

Each week you can find me linking to these fun parties.


Leave a Reply